What is a CCA Appeal?

In NSW, the Court of Criminal Appeal is the state’s highest court for reviewing criminal cases, providing a vital opportunity for individuals to seek a review of their conviction or sentence. This allows someone who believes their trial was unfair or their sentence unjust to have the case examined by experienced judges.

Types of Appeals

A person may appeal a conviction, arguing they were wrongly found guilty, or they may appeal the severity of their sentence, claiming it was excessive or disproportionate.

In some cases, the Crown (prosecution) can also appeal if they believe a sentence was too lenient.

Grounds for Appeal

To pursue an appeal, the appellant (the person appealing) generally needs to show that a legal error or miscarriage of justice occurred in the original trial.

Examples of appealable issues include improper directions given to the jury, wrongful admission or exclusion of evidence, or procedural errors that could have impacted the fairness of the trial.

These grounds are essential, as appeals cannot be based solely on dissatisfaction with the outcome—there must be legitimate legal reasons.

The Appeal Process

First, an appellant must apply for leave (permission) to appeal, which involves submitting their reasons to the CCA.

If the court grants leave, a panel of judges will review the evidence, trial records, and arguments from both sides. They have the power to make a number of decisions (see next slide) on such evidence.

The appeals process is thorough and meticulous, as the court weighs the evidence and law carefully to reach a fair conclusion.

Decisions Open to the CCA

1. Dismiss the Appeal

If the CCA finds no substantial errors in the original trial, they may dismiss the appeal. This means the original conviction or sentence remains as it is.

2. Quash the Conviction

If the court identifies a serious error or miscarriage of justice, they may quash (overturn) the conviction. This action effectively nullifies the original guilty verdict.

3. Vary the Sentence

For sentence appeals, the CCA can increase or decrease the sentence if they find that it was manifestly excessive or too lenient.

4. Order a Retrial

Where the court believes the trial was flawed but there’s still a case to answer, they may order a retrial. This means the accused will go through another trial with the same charges, giving them a new chance to defend themselves, while the Crown can also present its evidence again.

4. Substitute a Conviction

If the CCA decides the conviction should have been for a lesser charge, they can substitute the conviction with a verdict for a lesser offense. For instance, a person convicted of a more serious crime might have their conviction adjusted to a related but less severe offence.

Why the CCA is Essential

The CCA acts as a safeguard within the justice system, ensuring that mistakes or injustices can be corrected.

By ensuring that errors are addressed, the CCA promotes fairness for all. CCA appeals are a complex but critical part of criminal justice. For those impacted by legal errors, it represents hope for rectifying wrongs and achieving just outcomes.

The CCA’s decisions serve as an important mechanism for ensuring justice, allowing the correction of legal errors while balancing fairness and accountability in the criminal justice system. These options provide paths to correct issues from the original trial, uphold just outcomes, and safeguard legal rights.

About Post Author

Brian Walker

B.Acc., GradDipLegPrac, Juris Dr
Barrister & Accountant.
Former Criminal Defence Solicitor. Former Federal Prosecutor for the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions prosecuting Commonwealth crimes relating to drugs and child exploitation. Former Australian Federal Police member litigating proceeds of crime matters. Former Australian Taxation Office employee investigating offshore tax evasion matters.

Post Created by Cassidy Pole, paralegal.

See author's posts